A brief BCS this week, a little amuse-bouche before a fuller edition shortly.
So last week I was featured in Social Enterprise UK’s new newspaper (NOT newsletter, they hasten to clarify), ‘The Antidote’, which was distributed as something of a coup de theatre (that’s Peter for you) at the Social Enterprise UK Awards 2026. Next week, you can catch me discussing the future of social enterprise, and the ethics and politics of this strange hybrid beast, with CEO Peter Holbrook and systems thinker entrepreneur Louise Graham.
So, in 2010, I took on my first CEO role, as the employed CEO of a social sector private business delivering support for NEET young people. Next, I set up and ran a tech start-up social enterprise for the homelessness charity, St Mungo’s. So, much as I’ve had some years away, I know the beast inside as well as out.
Over that period, I came to find myself horrified by what I often saw: during the Big Society Bonanza, it was often simply used as a way of rebranding profiteering enterprises who wanted to get into the emerging markets attached to the utterly transparent privatisation agenda of the new Con-Dem Government. On the other hand, there were many charities who had seen the allure and culture capital that the sexiness of entrepreneur culture could bring. They moved quickly to prop up the idea that all social care and community could be delivered in a way that is somehow without cost, and self-sustaining, or even profitable.
This was always nuts. In some cases, yes, it can be done really well (for example, I’ve worked with an incredible SE nursery). But looking after people is not something that happens magically. As a society we have to choose it, and I’ve always believed it is right and proper that we use or our resources to do this. Directly. Even with money. I know, shocker.
But the ideological purpose that SE was often put to at that point was to conceal the dissolution of public sector services by projecting a patina of San Francisco start-up innovation culture over the top of austerity. I sometimes felt enraged in social enterprise conferences when I saw this happening and being completely unquestioned.
So for years, I became not just disillusioned, but deeply suspicious, of the SE world.
And yet, over the last couple of years, that has started to shift somewhat. Reading Mariana Mazzucato’s work had an impact on me. (I haven’t read the new one…. too deep in 17th century charity history…) She is still more of a straight down the line capitalist than I am, but a fully reconstructed and ethical one - Mazzucato’s talk about returning to a stakeholder capitalism, not just shareholder capitalism, was especially helpful. She pointed out that at one point, there were many people ‘around the table’, and whose needs were considered in capitalism - workers, community, society, not just shareholders. This sharpened considerably in neoliberal economics at the end of the 1970s. Business’s goal became not to contribute to society but to contribute to shareholder value alone.
Now, I would go further along the redistribution line than Mazzucato in many ways. But what I have become more interested in is the idea that social enterprise could be the very place where we test out new ideas of what enterprise can be. NOT, as previously, ways of trying out new ideas of what the social can be. If our primary goal is to make social goals more efficient or ‘enterprising’, I think we are looking at the wrong thing. Not least, private profit is profoundly wasteful. I also remain suspicious of models like the B-Corp which seem to me to very happily simply put some ‘values’ on top of the same old extraction and profiteering. After all, how could they not? Corporate law has enshrined the profit-above-all imperative into the very fabric of business.
Could we ‘do business’ that undermines some of the fundamentals of enterprise? For example, ‘efficiency’ is always defined by profitability. As Foucault noted, neoliberalism is the only worldview ever that believed every single thing could be explained by one single bottom line, and one single calculation: the profit or loss, the surplus or deficit. Society itself can be explained (controlled, and managed.simply by a number on a balance sheet.
I think social enterprise has a chance to move away from this, and what strikes me is that with social enterprise we have a radically open question we do not normally have in business:
What do we value?
Specifically, what do we value above and over financial profit?
Connectedly, we can also decide what we are willing to allow which is ‘inefficient’. A sense of ‘deficit’ or inefficiency as defined by capitalism, is fundamental to the model of social enterprise.
As I’ve noted many times, we have long taken those prevailing ideas and shapes and taken them even into the public sector, and even the charity sector, especially during the era of New Labour. As Mazzucato notes, that idea of ‘efficiency’ has been imported into a public sector where providing and supporting society and citizens should be the thing we value in itself - not simply the economic value or saving of money for the public purse. Outside of neoliberal capitalism, these shapes make no sense. And yet, they come to design and shape everything we do, and they come to decide what, and who, is worth our time and effort.
For example: working with, say, learning disabled people to make sandwiches is often ‘inefficient’. Having your cafe or library open even when it’s quiet, or a cinema when there may not be many people in the auditorium, is inefficient. But again, what do we value? This is only inefficient if our sole goal is maximising profit. Whose needs matter? What do we value beyond the bottom line?
It is worth noting that many businesses across the world operate in this way and do not call themselves social enterprises. After all, my ‘business’ does not ‘make a profit’. I It just makes a living. And I do it to eat, yes, but I also do it because I care about my world, my community, and the people I work with, and I want to make good things happen. This is not the alien concept that it is now presented as in standard economic discourse - in fact, it probably describes the majority of enterprises, not just in the world, but in history.
Our public discourses, and sadly, the ideological drivers and managers of our economy, have told us for so long that profit for shareholders is the only acceptable thing we can value. But most of us don’t actually believe that.
I think social enterprise could become one potential act of resistance directly in economy, that creates an alternative. But it does need to choose that. It needs to show what it is doing. And it needs to stop using the same measures, and same discourses of value, as the standard neoliberal model it may be able to contest.
As we look at a world where some of the most prominent political figures of our time are now finally willing to say that neoliberalism has run its nasty course - including our own Prime Minister - I think it may be time for social enterprise to come of age.
You can sign up for the event here.
Well, that was short and sweet. See you soon for more BCS fun.
Meanwhile, don’t forget one of the best ways to support this blog is to work with me in my day job.
Support!
Reading this work is free. But if you like it, a coffee is really appreciated.
Send me a message
I love hearing from readers. Drop me a line!







